In between fantasizing about my weekly pizza excursion and photographing it, I’ve got to order it. While I wish I could skip right to the pizza-eating part, first I’ve got to pick up the phone, express my vision to the pizza guy and get the logistics figured out.
Though I love pizza, I tend to have mixed feelings placing my order.
Of course, there’s an inherent joy in pitching my weekly plan to another person willing to listen, especially someone who will play a roll in executing it.
And, having a person on the line makes it easier to articulate complex orders and confirm any important questions that may arise (How thin is the thin-crust? Do you cut your pizza’s in triangles or squares?).
But, there’s the chance that interaction feels like a necessary evil—a social exchange so poor that it’s hard to find pleasure afterward.
I’m talking about the times when nothing is confirmed or heard properly and we aren’t even upsold extra cheese (come on, basics!). Sometimes the communication is so bad our pizza-night lands in a pickle as we end up with incorrect items, missing toppings and no sides of sauce.
With the prevalence of online ordering, we don’t need to worry about these situations as much anymore, but technical difficulties and peak order periods that cause shops to unplug are still ordinary, meaning we’re faced with picking up the phone and calling in our orders old-school.
When handling information as delicate as someone’s pizza order, it’s evident the employees manning the phones have a great responsibily and must have the utmost attention to detail. They set the tone for the entire experience—their demeanor, pace, and politeness in that initial contact is crucial.
When I want fuss-free ordering I turn to a spot where the front line employees excel and a great customer service experience is almost guaranteed.
Rosati’s West in Madison.
When it comes to phone order taking, I consider Rosasti’s West on Mineral Point Road to be masters (at least in my experience, in which there are many). They are kind, competent, concise and pleasantly nail the interaction every single time. They repeat everything back to you and will take on most requests.
Beyond killer customer service, you also get the option of “super-thin crust” if you’re in the “know”. Perhaps the greatest pizza hack of all-time besides “extra-cheese”; all you have to do is ask and they’ll gladly give your crust an extra spin through the dough rolling machine.
Any place that has the option of “super-thin” is good in my book, so I usually go with super-thin, extra cheese and maybe some pepperoni or green olives. Some nights if I’m feeling frisky I may even venture further into the menu and throw myself a little “Chicago Thanksgiving” complete with an Italian beef sandwich, Chicago style hotdog, and maybe even a calzone.
A botched interaction is more expensive than you might think.
The pain-free ordering at Rosati’s greatly increases my to desire to eat there, so I return to them regularly.
On the other hand, a pain-filled ordering experience can haunt me for months and causes me to pause, consider my choices, no matter how good a spots grub might be—I just don’t want to deal with shenanigans when it’s pizza time.
These days with so many options at our fingertips it’s easier than ever for customers to fall in and out of love with a restaurant based simply on their service and it’s harder than ever to regain that trust and loyalty. One wrong order, miscommunication or argument and that customer could be gone for good and that could mean losing out on big bucks for the restaurant.
In Seth Godin’s book, This is Marketing he urges businesses to consider the “lifetime value” of a customer when interacting with them. It takes massive amounts of time, money and energy to earn the business of new customers, so when you’ve got them it’s critical to treat them well, woo them and hopefully retain their business to make good on your investment.
One customer can add up to thousands of dollars in sales over the course of a lifetime of repeat orders. So, there’s no time to mess around with anything less than stellar service.
What pizza taught me:
A pleasant encounter can make our day, especially if there’s pizza afterward. Considerate and concise communication is something to strive for—a worthy pursuit that will undoubtedly yield more than well-executed pizza orders.
What I’m eating: Rosati’s “super-thin crust” green olive, extra cheese
What I’m reading: This is Marketing: You Can’t Be Seen Until You Learn To See –Seth Godin